The Cowboys faced a tough reality check after their Week 2 loss to the New Orleans Saints. The defeat, especially at home, highlighted several of the team’s ongoing issues, particularly within their backfield. Through two games, Dallas ranks near the bottom of the league in rushing, managing only 85.0 yards per game. This lackluster performance is a far cry from the 112.9 rushing yards per game the team averaged last season, leaving fans disappointed with the current state of the run game, and especially Elliott.
Declining Performance: A Tough Pill to Swallow
Elliott’s return to Dallas has been less than impressive. While fans didn’t expect him to perform like he did in his prime years of 2016 or 2018, many hoped for more than what he’s delivered thus far. In his first two games, Elliott has managed only 56 rushing yards on 16 carries, scoring a single touchdown. His average of 3.5 yards per carry is identical to last year’s figure, when he played behind a struggling New England Patriots offensive line — a worrying sign for Dallas.
Expectations were high for Elliott to make improvements upon returning to familiar territory, but reality has been underwhelming. In Week 2, five of his six carries went for three or fewer yards, an indication that his once-dominant presence on the field is fading. Fans who once cheered for his big plays are now left wondering if Elliott still has what it takes to be effective at this stage of his career.
Despite his loyal fan base, it’s becoming increasingly clear that Elliott is no longer the force he once was. His athleticism has noticeably declined, and his reduced speed and strength are evident in his struggles. Pro Football Focus graded Elliott’s rushing performance at just 49.1, ranking him among the lowest-performing running backs in the league — a stark contrast to his previous status as one of the NFL’s elite.
Cowboys’ Offseason Decisions Under Scrutiny
The decision to bring Elliott back becomes more questionable when considering the Cowboys’ offseason choices. After letting Tony Pollard walk in free agency, Dallas passed on other high-profile free agents like Saquon Barkley and Derrick Henry, only to settle for a declining Elliott. Fans and analysts alike are beginning to question the team’s judgment, particularly owner Jerry Jones’ commitment to the veteran running back.
Elliott’s struggles have not gone unnoticed on social media, where fans have been vocal in their criticism. One frustrated Cowboys supporter wrote, “Every single play that Ezekiel Elliott is the focus for the offense is a wasted rep.” Another fan lamented, “We really brought back an old Ezekiel Elliott,” expressing disappointment with the team’s decisions. These sentiments reflect a growing sense of frustration among the fan base, who are looking for answers as the team stumbles out of the gate this season.
As Dallas prepares for a challenging Week 3 matchup against the Baltimore Ravens, the pressure is on for Elliott to step up. The Cowboys enter the game as 1.5-point underdogs, and the team could use a strong performance from their veteran running back to help turn things around. Whether Elliott can silence the critics and rediscover his form remains to be seen, but for now, the reunion that once sparked hope has left Cowboys fans with more questions than answers.